COVID-19 UPDATE: In spite of the pandemic, our office remains open and our hours are the same. Please call us today so we can best accommodate you. We hope you and your family stay and remain safe.

Manhattan: 212-668-0100 Long Island: 516-535-6666
Brooklyn/Queens/Bronx/Staten Island: 718-SERIOUS(737-4687)

Available 24/7 | Free Consultation

No Fee Until We Win

Serious Injuries Require
Serious Lawyers

HomeInterview With Ira Perlman Concerning Slip-And-Fall AccidentsCommon Misconceptions About Slip & Fall Cases

What Are The Common Misconceptions That People Have About Slip-&-Fall Cases?

Many people have a misconception that merely because they fell and have an injury, they are automatically entitled to money. This is not the case. In order to obtain a damages award or settlement in a slip-and-fall case, a person must prove responsibility on the part of whoever was in charge of maintaining the subject location or property. Therefore, there are always two important elements to slip-and-fall accident cases.

The accident itself must give rise to some partial or complete fault on someone else’s part. You need to prove liability on the part of whoever you feel is responsible for the conditions causing you to fall. Once and only once you have done that are you entitled to receive monetary damages for the pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment and loss of daily activities.

Generally, the misconception looks like this: “Well, I had an accident. I am entitled to money right away, and it is just a question of how much.” It’s just not true and not that simple.

How Would You Respond To Someone Asking How Much Their Slip-And-Fall Case Is Worth?

The question cannot be answered without knowing more information about the true and full extent of the injuries, harm and other damages that resulted from the slip and fall. Obviously, cases have different values depending upon different variables.

A particular injury will often determine initially what type of dollar value a case has. After the true and full extent of the injuries are known, other variables, such as loss of earnings, medical costs, etc., can be considered when determining the full value of the case. Additionally, determining whether or not the sued defendant is entirely responsible for the injuries or whether the victim also bears some responsibility for the accident can also affect the value of the claim or case.

Of course, if the defendant is 100% responsible for the accident, then no reduction in the value of the case should occur. However, if for some reason the victim was negligent due to not seeing what was there to be seen or should have been seen and the accident could have been avoided, then the party who is being sued and his or her insurance carrier will always claim it is not entirely responsible and the value of the case should be reduced. For example, if the case was worth $100,000 and the victim was 25% responsible, then the case would be worth $75,000.

Would A Landlord Be Liable If A Resident Of The Apartment Complex Suffered Injuries After A Slip And Fall On The Landlord’s Property?

People use the term landlord loosely. Usually, the landlord, from a lawyer’s perspective, is the owner of the property. As an owner of the property, the owner would certainly be responsible for any dangerous slip-and-fall conditions, and merely because a person is a tenant in that building does not take away the landlord’s responsibility. Additionally, the managing agent in charge of operating or managing the building could also bear responsibility, especially if the owner has a separate company or individual managing that building. There are many common areas inside multiple dwellings/apartment buildings such as lobbies, vestibules, laundry rooms, elevator banks and common hallways, not to mention stairways that must be maintained by landlords and their agents.

Who Would Be Responsible If Someone Fell Down Their Neighbor’s Or Friend’s Steps: The Tenant Or The Person Who Owns The Property?

This gets a little complicated because a person cannot expect an owner or a landlord of a building to be responsible for every accident or every injury that takes place in an area of the building that is not under the landlord’s control, or in areas where the owner or landlord does not have a responsibility to maintain on a regular basis.

As I stated earlier, there are common areas throughout many buildings. Certainly, the landlord would be responsible to maintain those areas and make sure they are in a safe and proper condition. Furthermore, if repairs are needed, the landlord must take care of those conditions.

The issue becomes a little more complicated inside an individual apartment because, at first glance, one would think that the landlord has responsibility merely because he owns the property. However, a landlord cannot be responsible for making repairs due to conditions that he is not aware of.

The landlord would be held responsible as long as it can be proven that he knew or should have known about a condition in a tenant’s private apartment. In this regard, landlords do have the responsibility to go into apartments periodically to make sure the equipment and fixtures in those apartments are in working order and that they are operating correctly.

Furthermore, any tenant residing in a particular apartment has a responsibility to notify the landlord concerning conditions that could pose a danger or cause an accident. Therefore, there could be shared responsibility for conditions inside a tenant’s apartment. A number of parties might be involved in the lawsuit. Likewise, if a tenant occupies an entire house leased from a landlord who doesn’t live there, the landlord is known as an absentee landlord. The absentee landlord still has a duty to take care of and repair conditions that the landlord knows exist on the property such as a leaky gutter or roof area that results in water on a pathway that turns to ice posing danger to people.

For more information, schedule a free initial consultation. Get the information and legal answers you’re seeking by contacting us online or by calling 212-668-0100 today.

Hands-On New York Attorneys You Can Actually
Talk To

Were you seriously injured or have you lost a loved one in a fatal accident? We’re here to answer any of your questions and help evaluate your legal options. Schedule your free consultation today.

Fields marked with an * are required

"*" indicates required fields


This website contains “attorney advertising”. The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. We invite you to contact us and welcome your calls, letters and electronic mail. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship.

The web site is designed to provide general information only and to help in the choice of appropriate legal counsel. The information contained herein should not be construed as legal advice. Legal jurisdictions differ on major and minor aspects of the law and each legal situation is unique; requiring that all legal situations be addressed with qualified legal counsel. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Submitting or receiving information or questions through this web site does not create an attorney client relationship. No attorney client relationships will exist unless you meet with one of our attorneys and sign a retainer agreement. Please do not submit any information that is case specific, personal or confidential.

If you have legal problem or issue you should always consult with a qualified lawyer experienced in the appropriate area of law. We would be glad to discuss your specific situation with you, should you so desire. Please fill out the contact form and we will respond to you.